Most small business owners believe a crisis is defined by the event itself. In reality, a crisis is defined by the story people tell themselves about the event. Crisis PR is not about hiding from that story. It is about shaping it with honesty, clarity and control.

This guide is designed to change the way founders think about crisis communication forever. Whether the issue is operational, financial, reputational or emotional, the principles are the same. The decisions you make in the first few hours determine how bad it becomes — and how quickly you can recover.

The psychology of a crisis: why founders react badly

A crisis hits at the intersection of stress, pride and fear. Most founders respond emotionally because:

• the business is personal
• the issue feels unfair or misrepresented
• there is fear of reputational damage
• there is instinct to defend rather than listen
• there is panic about losing customers or trust

Most people imagine that crises expose weakness. But more often, crises expose instinct. And instinct, in crisis mode, is almost always unhelpful.

Your instinct tells you to respond immediately.
Good PR tells you to pause.
Your instinct tells you to defend yourself.
Good PR tells you to understand the situation first.
Your instinct tells you to minimise the problem.
Good PR tells you to be honest and direct.

Crisis PR requires discipline.
It requires emotional regulation.
It requires awareness that the narrative is bigger than your personal reaction.

‍

What a PR crisis actually is

A crisis is not the outage, the complaint, the lost parcel, the staffing issue, the negative review or the legal dispute.

A crisis is:

when perception becomes more damaging than reality.

Small businesses face crises in several forms:

1. Operational failures

Product defects, delays, outages, stock issues, system errors.

2. Financial or cashflow issues

Delayed payments, payroll mistakes, supplier defaults.

3. Legal or compliance breaches

Anything that creates risk, confusion or public concern.

4. Customer harm or safety issues

Health, data, wellbeing, or physical safety.

5. Staff misconduct

Anything that impacts trust or brand values.

6. Founder behaviour

The hardest crisis of all — because the spotlight turns inward.

Understanding the type of crisis helps define the required response, tone, and timeline.

The first hour: the 60-minute framework that prevents disaster

The biggest PR disasters rarely come from the actual event.
They come from poor reactions in the first hour.

Use this framework as your crisis autopilot.

1. Pause

Do not post. Do not email. Do not comment. Do not defend.
Silence is valuable — panic is expensive.

2. Gather facts

You need truth, not noise.
Speak to your team, check the system, verify details, review logs or reports.

3. Assess severity

Create a quick rating:

• low (internal issue)
• medium (customer-impacting)
• high (trust, safety or reputation risk)
• critical (public or legal exposure)

4. Build the narrative

This is not spin. This is context.
Your narrative should answer three questions:

• what happened
• what it means
• what you are doing next

5. Decide who speaks

In small businesses, the founder is often the voice during high-severity crises.
For lower-severity issues, operations or customer support may be appropriate.

6. Communicate internally first

Your team must never learn about a crisis from the public.
Internal alignment prevents misinformation, fear, or contradictory messaging.

7. Prepare the public response

Only after the above steps are complete.
Speed matters — but accuracy matters more.

This first hour determines the next 24 hours.

‍

What to say: the 5 Cs of crisis communication

Great crisis PR is not poetic. It is structured. It is disciplined. It is transparent.
Use this Thriday-style framework to craft statements that build trust.

1. Clarity

Be precise, avoid vagueness.
“Yesterday at 3pm our payment system experienced an interruption affecting 17 customers.”

2. Candour

Own the issue without defensiveness.
“This should not have happened, and we understand the frustration it caused.”

3. Competence

Explain your plan to fix it.
“Our team has identified the cause and implemented a permanent solution.”

4. Care

Show empathy without theatrics.
“We know how disruptive this was to your business, and we are genuinely sorry.”

5. Control

End with confident next steps.
“You can expect a further update by 5pm today.”

This framework works for emails, public statements, inbox messages, phone calls, and social posts.

What not to say: the seven deadly sins of crisis PR

These are the mistakes that turn small issues into big scandals.

1. Over-apologising

Excessive apology signals lack of control.

2. Under-apologising

A cold or defensive tone accelerates backlash.

3. Blaming others

Customers do not care whose “fault” it was.

4. Vagueness

“We’re looking into it” creates suspicion.

5. Legal jargon

It makes you sound calculated rather than responsible.

6. Posting emotionally

An emotional founder can pour fuel on a fire.

7. Going silent

Silence is interpreted as avoidance, not professionalism.

‍

Internal communication during crisis: the part most founders ignore

External narrative only stabilises once the internal narrative is aligned.
Staff must know:

• what happened
• what they should say
• what they should not say
• how to handle incoming customer questions
• how often updates will be provided

A good rule:
If your staff do not understand the crisis, your customers never will.

Your team will mirror your emotional state.
If you are calm, they will be calm.
If you are scattered, they will be scattered.

Customers in crisis: how to protect trust

How you treat customers during a crisis becomes your brand.

Notify affected customers first

They should never discover the issue on social media before hearing from you.

Be transparent about the impact

Customers value honesty over perfection.

Offer remedies or compensation when appropriate

It shows responsibility, not guilt.

Use the rule of three for angry customers

• acknowledge
• clarify
• resolve

Follow up once the issue is fixed

Closing the loop creates loyalty.

A crisis handled gracefully is often remembered more positively than a business that never had one.

Handling press, social media and public scrutiny

Social media accelerates crises faster than traditional press.
A single tweet or review can escalate into a narrative if not handled well.

Have a holding statement ready

Short, factual, calm.
This buys time for a full response.

Engage selectively

Respond to clarity-seeking questions, not to attacks or arguments.

Assume everything is public

There is no such thing as an “off-the-record” DM.

Limit the number of people speaking for the business

One voice = consistency.
Multiple voices = chaos.

Update regularly

Uncertainty creates fear.
Information creates stability.

Legal vs PR: balancing risk and reputation

Legal and PR have different objectives:

• Legal wants to minimise liability.
• PR wants to preserve trust.

In a crisis, both matter — but small businesses need a practical balance.

When to prioritise PR

When customers are confused, anxious or angry.
When the brand is being criticised publicly.

When to prioritise legal

When there is regulatory, compliance or safety exposure.

The trick is to speak honestly without admitting fault you have not confirmed.
You can be transparent without being reckless.

Case studies: what small businesses can learn

Stories make lessons stick. Here are examples founders will recognise:

A restaurant accused of a food safety issue

Poor response: defensive denial.
Strong response: immediate closure for inspection, clear updates, and sincere care for customers.

A retail business facing a defective product batch

Poor response: hiding the issue and hoping complaints stop.
Strong response: voluntary recall, transparent explanation, proactive outreach.

A tech platform experiencing unreliable service

Poor response: blaming third-party providers.
Strong response: outlining a roadmap to fix underlying reliability and committing to better communication.

Each example reinforces the truth:
A crisis is not defined by the event — but by the response.

How crisis PR transforms you as a leader

Crises change founders in ways that success never does.

You learn to breathe before reacting.
You learn the power of calm leadership.
You understand your team’s strengths and vulnerabilities.
You discover who in your organisation rises under pressure.
You realise trust is built fastest when you are most exposed.

A crisis is painful — but it is also clarifying.
It reveals the values that were real and exposes the ones that were aspirational.

Building a crisis-resilient company before the crisis hits

Most small businesses only think about crisis PR after something goes wrong.
But resilience is built in advance.

Have a crisis playbook

Quick steps, key contacts, messaging templates.

Train your team on communication etiquette

Not everyone understands how to speak publicly.

Automate financial and operational processes

The businesses that recover fastest are the ones with clean data, accurate records and disciplined cashflow.
This is where platforms like Thriday give small businesses an unfair advantage.

Monitor sentiment

Social channels, support tickets, reviews — these are early warning signals.

Run simulations

What would you do if your service went down for two hours?
If a product batch failed?
If a key staff member caused a public issue?

Preparation turns panic into professionalism.

Key takeaways

Every founder will face a crisis.
Most will face several.

But crises are not the end of a business — they are often the beginning of a more resilient, mature and trusted one. They expose the fractures you ignored, reveal the strength you underestimated, and force the evolution you postponed.

The goal of crisis PR is not perfection; it is leadership.
It is clarity in chaos.
It is responsibility in uncertainty.
It is the courage to face the moment rather than hide from it.

When everything goes wrong, your customers do not need you to be flawless.
They need you to be honest, calm and in control.

Because a crisis does not define how your story ends but how you respond defines who you become.