Small Business Glossary

Cost-benefit analysis (CBA)

Cost-benefit analysis (CBA) is a methodical approach used to assess the potential advantages and disadvantages of a decision, project, or policy. It involves identifying, measuring, and comparing the expected costs associated with a particular option against the anticipated benefits it will bring.
Contents

What's the Purpose of a Cost Benefit Analysis?

Cost Benefit Analysis helps individuals and businesses make informed decisions by providing a structured framework to evaluate alternatives. It aims to determine whether the projected benefits outweigh the costs, ultimately indicating if a course of action is worthwhile.

What does a cost-benefit analysis typically involve?

  • Identifying all relevant costs and benefits, both tangible (financial) and intangible (non-financial).
  • Assigning a monetary value to the quantifiable costs and benefits whenever possible.
  • Comparing the total benefits against the total costs to determine if the option creates net positive value.
  • Considering alternative options and conducting a comparative analysis.

What are the benefits of doing a cost-benefit analysis?

  • Provides a data-driven approach to decision-making, reducing reliance on intuition or bias.
  • Simplifies complex choices by clearly outlining the potential costs and benefits.
  • Uncovers hidden aspects by prompting a comprehensive analysis of all potential impacts.

What are the limitations of a cost-benefit analysis?

  • Difficulty in accurately predicting all future variables and outcomes.
  • Reliance on accurate data to avoid skewed results.
  • Can be less effective for long-term projects with high uncertainty.
  • May struggle to assign a dollar value to intangible benefits or costs.

Overall, cost-benefit analysis is a valuable tool for informed decision-making across various sectors in Australia.

Cost-benefit analysis example

Upgrading Delivery Vehicles for a Sydney Bakery

Business: Le Pain Doré, a small bakery located in Sydney

Decision: Upgrading from two older delivery vans to two fuel-efficient hybrid vans.

Costs:

  • Financial:
    • Purchase cost of two new hybrid vans: AU$80,000
    • Disposal costs of old vans: AU$2,000
    • Potential maintenance cost increase (due to newer technology):  AU$1,000 per van annually
  • Non-financial:
    • Training staff on operating new vans
    • Downtime during the transition to new vehicles (potential loss of sales)

Benefits:

  • Financial:
    • Reduced fuel costs (estimated 30% decrease)
    • Potential tax benefits for environmentally friendly vehicles
    • Increased delivery capacity with larger cargo space (potentially leading to more sales)
    • Lower maintenance costs in the long run (due to hybrid technology)
  • Non-financial:
    • Improved brand image due to focus on sustainability
    • Enhanced employee morale with newer, more comfortable vehicles
    • Reduced environmental impact

Analysis:

  • The initial investment (purchase and disposal) is AU$82,000.
  • Potential annual fuel cost savings could be substantial, depending on fuel prices. Let's assume AU$10,000 per van annually.
  • Increased maintenance costs would be AU$2,000 per year.
  • The potential for increased sales and tax benefits are harder to quantify but should be factored in qualitatively.

Considering a 5-year timeframe:

  • Total upfront cost: AU$82,000
  • Total potential fuel cost savings: AU$50,000 (AU$10,000 x 2 vans x 5 years)
  • Increased maintenance costs: AU$10,000 (AU$2,000 x 2 vans x 5 years)

Based on these simplified figures, there appears to be a net financial benefit after year 3. However, the  decision should also consider the intangible benefits and potential for increased sales.

Conclusion:

Upgrading the delivery vans appears to be a financially sound decision in the long term.  The cost-benefit analysis provides a framework, but the bakery owner should also consider:

  • The impact of potential increased sales on profitability.
  • The value of the improved brand image and employee satisfaction.
  • The availability of government incentives for environmentally friendly vehicles.

By incorporating these factors, Le Pain Doré can make a well-informed decision about upgrading their delivery fleet.

Why waste time on financial admin when Thriday can do it for you?

JOIN FOR FREE
Already have an account? Login here
Thriday Debit Card